# Temptation Bundling: What the Gym Audiobook Study Found

Published 2026-11-19, updated 2026-11-19. Online at https://thenuttracker.com/blog/temptation-bundling-gym-audiobook-study-what-it-found

In one field experiment, people who could only hear gripping audiobooks at the gym visited 51% more often than a control group at first. The effect faded after Thanksgiving.

You have probably put something off while a better option sat right there. Temptation bundling is a researcher's name for tying the two together, so the treat only shows up with the task. Here is what the best-known test measured, and where the numbers stop.

## What is temptation bundling?

Temptation bundling pairs an enjoyable "want" activity with a "should" behavior. The classic example is a page-turner audiobook that you only get to hear while exercising.

The idea comes from a 2014 paper in [Management Science](https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:inm:ormnsc:v:60:y:2014:i:2:p:283-299) by Katherine Milkman, Julia Minson and Kevin Volpp. They call it a commitment device: a way to bind your future self to a plan. The paper's title, "Holding the Hunger Games Hostage at the Gym," tells you which treat they chose.

## How did the gym audiobook study work?

It was a field experiment with 226 people at a large university in the northeastern United States. According to the [full paper](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4381662/), they signed up in September 2011 for a paid exercise study and were randomly placed into one of three groups.

| Group | People | What they got |
|---|---|---|
| Full treatment | 75 | Audio novels on an iPod kept in a monitored locker at the gym |
| Intermediate | 75 | The same kind of novels on their own iPod, plus encouragement to listen only while exercising |
| Control | 76 | A $25 bookstore gift certificate |

Visits were counted from electronic ID swipes at the gym. Participants were 34% men and 86% undergraduates. In the first week they averaged 1.5 visits, and 40% did not go at all.

The three setups differ in how firm the rule is. In the full treatment group the rule was enforced, because the iPod never left the gym. In the intermediate group it was only suggested, and the book was in their pocket the whole time. The control group got a gift certificate that pretests judged equal in value to four audio novels, so any gap was not just about getting a free present.

## What did the three groups do?

Early on, the full treatment group visited 51% more often than the control group, and the intermediate group visited 29% more often. Both numbers come from the paper's abstract.

[Knowledge at Wharton](https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/researchers-used-hunger-games-encourage-healthier-choices/) adds that the novels came from 82 pre-tested titles judged highly tempting, including The Hunger Games, The Da Vinci Code and the Twilight series.

After the study ended, 61% of participants chose to pay for gym-only access to iPods loaded with tempting audiobooks. Wharton reports an average price of $6.91. The authors read that as demand for a commitment device.

## Why did the effect fade after Thanksgiving?

The paper reports that treatment effects declined over time, particularly following Thanksgiving. Wharton describes a sharp drop in gym attendance for all groups when participants left campus for the break, and says the benefits wore off.

The researchers didn't claim to have fixed that. They listed two open questions: how to sustain the early benefit, and how to re-engage people with tempting content after time away from the gym.

If a break knocking out a routine sounds familiar, two other posts cover nearby ground: [if-then plans](/blog/if-then-plans-habits-what-research-found) and [how long a habit takes to form](/blog/how-long-to-form-a-habit-66-day-study).

## What can this study not tell us?

It can't tell you what a bundle would do for you. It counted gym visits, not effort, and the authors say they could not directly measure how much people exercised. It covered 226 people at one school, mostly undergraduates, who had signed up for an exercise study.

The paper is also described by its authors as just one investigation of temptation bundling. Volpp told Wharton the concept is highly promising but "not ready for prime time and large-scale application yet."

For a different angle on what small incentives do, see [rewards and habits](/blog/do-rewards-help-habit-stick-research). More like this lives in [habits](/blog/category/habits) and the [full blog](/blog).

## Tracking it yourself

A study average says little about one person. The useful move is to look at your own pattern, not to copy the study. If you pair something with a habit, log the pairing, whether you showed up, and what the weeks around a break looked like.

The Nut Tracker keeps entries with a rating, tags, mood and a note, then shows streaks, stats and a calendar, all stored on your phone with no account. A tag for "paired with a treat" would let you compare those days with the rest, and [what happens after a missed day](/blog/why-people-quit-streaks-what-the-hell-effect) is a pattern a calendar makes easy to spot. Look at whether the tagged days cluster early in a stretch, and whether they thin out after a trip or a holiday, which is the part the study saw fade. You can start at [the app page](/).

## Bottom line

One field experiment found that tying a gripping audiobook to the gym was followed by more gym visits at first, and that the gap faded after a holiday break. It is a small, single-campus study, so treat it as an observation, not a promise.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What is temptation bundling?

It means pairing something you enjoy, such as a gripping audiobook, with something you tend to put off, such as a gym visit. The researchers who named it call the first a want and the second a should.

### How big was the gym audiobook study?

It had 226 people at one U.S. university, randomly split into a full treatment group of 75, an intermediate group of 75 and a control group of 76.

### Did the effect last?

Not fully. The authors report that treatment effects declined over time, particularly following Thanksgiving break.

### Does one study settle it?

No. The authors describe the paper as one investigation of temptation bundling, and a Wharton researcher said the idea was not ready for large-scale application.

## Questions

### What is temptation bundling?

It means pairing something you enjoy, such as a gripping audiobook, with something you tend to put off, such as a gym visit. The researchers who named it call the first a want and the second a should.

### How big was the gym audiobook study?

It had 226 people at one U.S. university, randomly split into a full treatment group of 75, an intermediate group of 75 and a control group of 76.

### Did the effect last?

Not fully. The authors report that treatment effects declined over time, particularly following Thanksgiving break.

### Does one study settle it?

No. The authors describe the paper as one investigation of temptation bundling, and a Wharton researcher said the idea was not ready for large-scale application.

## Sources

- [Management Science via PMC: Holding the Hunger Games Hostage at the Gym: An Evaluation of Temptation Bundling](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4381662/)
- [Knowledge at Wharton: Using 'The Hunger Games' to Encourage Healthier Choices](https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/researchers-used-hunger-games-encourage-healthier-choices/)
- [EconPapers: Holding the Hunger Games Hostage at the Gym (Management Science, 2014)](https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:inm:ormnsc:v:60:y:2014:i:2:p:283-299)
