# Badges and Points: Do Game Elements Help People Keep a Habit?

Published 2026-11-18, updated 2026-11-18. Online at https://thenuttracker.com/blog/badges-points-game-elements-habit-apps-research

Reviews of gamified apps found small, mixed gains in physical activity. The studies bundled badges, points and other elements together, so no one can say which piece did the work. Most had no follow-up.

The app buzzes, a badge pops up, and you feel a small flick of pride. Nice moment. Does it do anything for the habit behind it? Researchers have been asking that about apps for years. One catch up front: the studies below measured physical activity, mostly steps and exercise, not any other habit. Here is what they counted, what they found, and what they could not separate out.

## What counts as a game element?

Gamification means using game pieces in a setting that is not a game, and the usual list is points, leaderboards, progress bars and badges.

That definition comes from a 2022 [systematic review in JMIR mHealth and uHealth](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8855282/), which also lists what the studies it covered really used. The most common element was goal-setting, followed by progress bars, rewards, points and feedback. Studies used between 1 and 10 elements, and most used about 5 at once.

Notice what that means. A "gamified app" in these papers is rarely just a badge. It's a bundle.

## What did the 50 study review find?

It found that gamification could increase physical activity, but the results were mixed and the changes were modest.

The authors screened 2,944 studies and kept 50. Of those, 30 (60%) paired the game elements with a wearable device, and 25 (50%) used a behavior theory to design the intervention. Their summary line is plain: results were mixed and modest, which they put down to how different the studies were from one another.

Two limits matter for a habit reader:

- 38 of the 50 studies (76%) had no follow-up, so there is little evidence on what happens later.
- The studies varied too much in design and data to be pooled into one number, so the authors could not run a meta-analysis.

The authors also say gamification interventions generally have short-term effects. And they note the evidence "might not be sufficiently strong" to say whether gamification works. Translation: the question is still open.

## What did the meta-analysis of standalone apps find?

A pooled analysis found a small to moderate effect in randomized trials, with a lot of spread between studies.

A 2022 [systematic review and meta-analysis by Yang, Hu and Koenigstorfer](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34893387/) looked at apps used on their own as the intervention. Nineteen studies were eligible, and 16 went into the pooling.

| | Randomized trials | Pre-to-post, no control group |
|---|---|---|
| Applications | 12 | 18 |
| Effect size (standardized mean difference) | 0.34 (95% CI 0.06 to 0.62) | 0.38 (95% CI 0.17 to 0.59) |
| Certainty of evidence | Moderate | Very low |
| Spread between studies (I2) | 72% | 74% |

A wide interval and a high I2 mean the studies disagreed a lot. The authors ran a leave-one-out check, which dropped the spread to 31% and 47.8%, and the main effects held. Their conclusion is hedged on purpose: standalone gamified apps "may" increase physical activity, and future work should isolate which features matter.

If you want to see how a similar question played out for logging itself, we covered [what 138 studies found about tracking your progress](/blog/does-tracking-goal-progress-work-138-studies).

## How big was the effect?

In the largest comparison, gamified apps beat non-gamified apps by about 489 steps a day, which the authors describe as a trivial increase.

A 2024 [meta-analysis of randomized trials](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11701442/) compared health apps with gamification against the same kind of app without it. It pooled 36 trials, 10,079 people, all lasting at least 8 weeks. The step difference was 489 steps a day (95% CI 64 to 914), rated high certainty. The interval runs from 64 to 914 steps, so the gap is real but small.

That study also looked at other outcomes. We leave those out here, since this is a piece about habit apps and not about what a body will do.

## Why are badges and points so hard to test on their own?

Because almost no study isolates them, so a result for "gamification" cannot be credited to any single element.

Both the meta-analysis and the 50 study review end in the same place: more research is needed on which elements do the work. The 50 study authors suggest that a combination of several game elements may work better than one. That is a guess about design, not a finding about badges.

There is a related question about reward in general, which we looked at in [what the research says about rewards](/blog/do-rewards-help-habit-stick-research). Reward is one of the elements the 50 study review lists, and like badges it was usually studied inside a bundle.

## What can you do with this in your own log?

You can treat a badge as a small data point about yourself, not as proof that the app is working on you.

The studies describe averages across many people. They can't tell you how a badge lands for you. Your own log can, a little. Look at the week before a badge and the week after. Did the thing you track change, or did you just feel good for a minute? A flat line is also an answer.

Streaks are the same trick in a different costume. They can sting when they break, which is [why people quit streaks](/blog/why-people-quit-streaks-what-the-hell-effect). If a number is making you tense instead of curious, it may be worth [tracking without obsessing over the numbers](/blog/healthy-self-tracking-without-obsessing-over-numbers).

The Nut Tracker, from Kallos Labs, has badges, streaks, a calendar and stats, with data kept on your phone. Read them the way you would read any study: as a report on what you logged, with limits. More in [the app category](/blog/category/the-app), or [start at the home page](/). Everything on the blog is at [/blog](/blog).

## Bottom line

Reviews of gamified apps found small, mixed gains in physical activity, mostly short term, with no way to credit badges or points specifically. Think of a badge as a nice moment, and your log as the place to check whether it did anything.

## Questions

### Do badges and points help you keep a habit?

Reviews of gamified apps found small to modest increases in physical activity on average, with mixed results across studies. They tested bundles of game elements, not badges or points alone, so nobody can say which element did the work.

### Were these studies about habits like No Nut November?

No. They measured physical activity, mostly steps and exercise. Whether the same pattern holds for other habits is not something these reviews tested.

### Do the effects last?

That is unclear. In the 50 study review, 38 studies had no follow-up, and the authors say gamification interventions generally have short-term effects.

### Does The Nut Tracker have badges?

Yes, the app has badges. This article reports what research found about game elements in general. It does not claim that badges change anything for you.

## Sources

- [JMIR mHealth and uHealth: The Effects of mHealth-Based Gamification Interventions on Participation in Physical Activity: Systematic Review](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8855282/)
- [PubMed: Effects of Gamified Smartphone Applications on Physical Activity: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34893387/)
- [PMC: Effect of digital health applications with or without gamification on physical activity and cardiometabolic risk factors](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11701442/)
